Office of Governor and Related Concerns - Polity And Governance | UPSC Learning
Topics
0 topics โข 0 completed
๐
No topics match your search

Office of Governor and Related Concerns
Mediumโฑ๏ธ 8 min read
polity and governance
๐ Introduction
<h4>Introduction: The Office of Governor</h4><p>The <strong>Governor</strong> serves as the <strong>constitutional head</strong> of a <strong>State</strong> in India, acting as a vital link between the <strong>Union</strong> and <strong>State</strong> governments.</p><p>Recently, the appointment and reappointment of Governors for various states like <strong>Manipur</strong>, <strong>Mizoram</strong>, and <strong>Bihar</strong> have brought the office into public discourse.</p><div class='exam-tip-box'><p>The <strong>Office of Governor</strong> is a recurring topic in <strong>UPSC Civil Services Exam</strong>, particularly in <strong>GS Paper II (Polity)</strong>, focusing on its constitutional provisions, powers, and controversies.</p></div><h4>Constitutional Provisions for the Governor</h4><p>The <strong>Constitution of India</strong> outlines the framework for the <strong>Governor's office</strong> through several key articles.</p><div class='info-box'><ul><li><strong>Article 153</strong>: Mandates a <strong>Governor</strong> for each <strong>State</strong>. It also allows the same person to be appointed as <strong>Governor</strong> for <strong>two or more States</strong>.</li><li><strong>Article 154</strong>: Vests the <strong>executive power</strong> of the <strong>State</strong> in the <strong>Governor</strong>. This power can be exercised directly or through subordinate officers.</li></ul></div><p>The <strong>Governor</strong> is generally bound by the <strong>advice of the Council of Ministers</strong>, making them a <strong>nominal head</strong>, similar to the <strong>President</strong> at the Union level.</p><h4>Appointment and Qualifications of the Governor</h4><p>The process for selecting a <strong>Governor</strong> is distinct from elected offices, emphasizing their role as a central appointee.</p><div class='info-box'><ul><li><strong>Appointment</strong>: <strong>Article 155</strong> states that the <strong>President of India</strong> appoints the <strong>Governor</strong> of a State.</li><li><strong>Nature of Office</strong>: Although appointed by the <strong>President</strong>, the <strong>Governor</strong> is not considered an <strong>employee of the Government of India</strong>.</li><li><strong>Office of Profit</strong>: A <strong>Governor</strong> must not hold any <strong>office of profit</strong> during their tenure.</li></ul></div><p>Specific criteria are laid down to ensure the suitability of candidates for this high constitutional office.</p><div class='key-point-box'><p><strong>Qualifications for Governor:</strong></p><ul><li>Must be a <strong>citizen of India</strong>.</li><li>Must be at least <strong>35 years old</strong>.</li><li>Must not be a <strong>member of Parliament</strong> or any <strong>State Legislature</strong>.</li></ul></div><h4>Oath of Office for the Governor</h4><p>Before assuming duties, the <strong>Governor</strong> undergoes a formal oath-taking ceremony, as prescribed by the <strong>Constitution</strong>.</p><div class='info-box'><p><strong>Article 159</strong> mandates that the <strong>Governor</strong> takes an <strong>oath or affirmation</strong> before the <strong>Chief Justice of the High Court</strong> of the concerned State, or in their absence, the <strong>senior-most available judge</strong> of that High Court.</p></div><h4>Legislative Powers of the Governor</h4><p>The <strong>Governor</strong> plays a crucial role in the <strong>State Legislature</strong>, exercising powers that impact the legislative process and government stability.</p><ul><li><strong>Dissolution of Assembly</strong>: Under <strong>Article 174</strong>, the <strong>Governor</strong> may recommend dissolving the <strong>Legislative Assembly</strong>. This power is exercised if no party can form a government or upon the <strong>Chief Minister's advice</strong>, but it is not entirely discretionary and is subject to specific conditions.</li><li><strong>Floor Test and Messages</strong>: <strong>Article 175(2)</strong> empowers the <strong>Governor</strong> to call for a <strong>floor test</strong> to verify the government's majority. They can also send messages to the legislature for consideration of bills or other matters.</li><li><strong>Address to Legislature</strong>: As per <strong>Article 176</strong>, the <strong>Governor</strong> addresses the legislature at the <strong>first session after general elections</strong> and <strong>annually</strong>, explaining the reasons for summoning the assembly or both Houses.</li><li><strong>Assent to Bills</strong>: Similar to the <strong>President</strong>, the <strong>Governor</strong> can delay assent to <strong>Money Bills</strong> and make recommendations. However, the legislature is not obligated to accept these recommendations.</li></ul><h4>Constitutional Discretionary Powers of the Governor</h4><p>While generally bound by advice, the <strong>Governor</strong> possesses certain <strong>discretionary powers</strong> that allow them to act independently in specific situations.</p><div class='key-point-box'><p><strong>Key Discretionary Powers:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Appointment of Chief Minister</strong>: When no party has a <strong>clear majority</strong> in the <strong>State Legislative Assembly</strong>, or when the incumbent <strong>Chief Minister dies suddenly</strong> without an obvious successor.</li><li><strong>Dismissal of Council of Ministers</strong>: If the <strong>Council of Ministers</strong> cannot prove the <strong>confidence of the State Legislature</strong>.</li><li><strong>Dissolution of Assembly</strong>: If the <strong>Council of Ministers</strong> has lost its majority and the <strong>Governor</strong> believes a stable government cannot be formed.</li><li><strong>Reserving a Bill for President's Consideration</strong>: This is an important discretionary power, enabling the Governor to refer certain state bills to the President for assent, especially those affecting central laws or national interest.</li></ul></div><h4>Term of Office and Removal of the Governor</h4><p>The <strong>Governor's term</strong> is linked to the <strong>President's pleasure</strong>, highlighting the central government's influence over the office.</p><div class='info-box'><ul><li><strong>Term Duration</strong>: <strong>Article 156</strong> stipulates that the <strong>Governor</strong> holds office during the <strong>pleasure of the President</strong>. The typical term is <strong>five years</strong> from the date of assuming office.</li><li><strong>Removal</strong>: The <strong>Governor</strong> can be dismissed by the <strong>President</strong>, usually on the <strong>advice of the Union Council of Ministers</strong> headed by the <strong>Prime Minister</strong>.</li><li><strong>Continuity</strong>: A <strong>Governor</strong> remains in office until their <strong>successor assumes charge</strong>, even if their five-year term has expired, ensuring no vacuum in the office.</li></ul></div><h4>Immunities Provided to the Governor under Article 361</h4><p>To ensure the independent functioning of the <strong>Governor's office</strong>, the <strong>Constitution</strong> grants specific immunities from legal proceedings.</p><h4>Origin and Rationale of Governor's Immunity</h4><p>The concept of immunity for high constitutional functionaries has historical roots and was debated during the drafting of the <strong>Indian Constitution</strong>.</p><div class='info-box'><p>The origin is linked to the <strong>Latin maxim "rex non potest peccare"</strong>, meaning <strong>"the king can do no wrong"</strong>.</p></div><p>During the <strong>Constituent Assembly discussions</strong> on <strong>Article 361</strong>, member <strong>H. V. Kamath</strong> raised concerns about the extent of criminal immunity for the <strong>President</strong> and <strong>Governors</strong>, questioning the initiation of proceedings for criminal acts.</p><p>Despite these concerns, <strong>Article 361</strong> was adopted without significant amendments, underscoring the framers' intent to provide robust protection to these offices.</p><h4>Specific Immunities under Article 361</h4><p><strong>Article 361</strong> provides comprehensive protection, making the <strong>Governor</strong> largely immune from legal challenges during their tenure.</p><div class='key-point-box'><p><strong>Key Immunities:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Non-Answerable to Courts (Article 361(1))</strong>: The <strong>President</strong> or <strong>Governor</strong> is not answerable to any court for the exercise and performance of their powers and duties, or for any act done in the exercise of those powers and duties. This provision is an exception to <strong>Article 14 (Right to Equality)</strong>.</li><li><strong>Protection from Criminal Proceedings (Article 361(2))</strong>: No <strong>criminal proceedings whatsoever</strong> can be instituted or continued against the <strong>President</strong> or <strong>Governor</strong> in any court during their term of office.</li><li><strong>No Arrest or Imprisonment (Article 361(3))</strong>: No process for the <strong>arrest or imprisonment</strong> of the <strong>President</strong> or <strong>Governor</strong> can be issued from any court during their term of office.</li><li><strong>Protection from Civil Proceedings (Article 361(4))</strong>: No <strong>civil lawsuits</strong> can be filed against the <strong>President</strong> or <strong>Governor</strong> during their term of office for any <strong>personal acts</strong> until <strong>two months after giving written notice</strong>.</li></ul></div><div class='exam-tip-box'><p>Understanding <strong>Article 361</strong> is crucial for Mains answers, especially when discussing the <strong>checks and balances</strong> or the <strong>special privileges</strong> of constitutional functionaries.</p></div>

๐ก Key Takeaways
- โขGovernor is the constitutional head of the state (Article 153, 154), appointed by the President (Article 155).
- โขQualifications: Indian citizen, 35+ years, not MP/MLA. Oath under Article 159 before HC Chief Justice.
- โขKey legislative powers include dissolving assembly (Article 174), floor test (Article 175(2)), addressing legislature (Article 176).
- โขConstitutional discretionary powers are crucial in hung assemblies, CM's sudden death, or reserving bills for President.
- โขTerm is 5 years, 'pleasure of President' (Article 156), can be dismissed by President on PM's advice.
- โขArticle 361 grants comprehensive immunities: no court answerability, no criminal proceedings, no arrest, limited civil proceedings after notice.
- โขThe office is a vital link between Union and State, often subject to debates on impartiality and federal balance, prompting reform recommendations.
๐ง Memory Techniques

95% Verified Content
๐ Reference Sources
โขConstitution of India (Articles 153-156, 159, 174-176, 361)